Pope Benedict XVI is currently here making his Holy Land pilgrimage and as I expected it seems much more political than it seems holy.
He really can't do or say anything right, because it's either going to be offensive to the Israelis or to the Palestinians. He has to prove to Jews that he is sorry about the Holocaust, he has to convince Muslims that he doesn't think Islam is evil, and he has to convince the Palestinian Christians that he hasn't forgotten about them. None of these things have to contradict each other, but when they're politicized, it's amazing how quickly you can turn them into opposing viewpoints.
A Palestinian Islamic cleric, Taysir Tamimi, gave an impromptu speech criticizing Israel's recent war in Gaza and its occupation of the West Bank at an interfaith gathering that the Pope was attending in Jerusalem. The Pope didn't react and then left. The Vatican later issued a condemnation, saying in a statement that "this intervention was a direct negation of what dialogue should be."
Don't get me wrong, I agree that an interfaith conference wasn't necessarily the place to start a political discussion, but I think Tamimi was taking an opportunity to do something that no Palestinian was offered to do on the Pope's trip here...to express the oppression that is imposed on the Palestinian people living here.
The Pope's trip in Israel/Palestine started in Tel Aviv (even though its on the opposite of the country from where he was coming from in Jordan), where there are no religious sites, but instead the Holocaust Memorial, Yad Vashem. Many Israelis were complaining that his language during his speech regarding the Holocaust was too vague.
Rabbi Israel Meir Lau, chairman of Yad Vashem and a former chief rabbi of Israel, stated in regards to the speech,
"There is a clear difference between 'killed' and 'murdered.' There is a difference between saying millions in the Holocaust and saying six million. The word six was not said."
Pope Benedict has his own reasons for having to mend ties with the Jewish community and to apologize for the Holocaust, such as his reputation of being a member of the Nazi Youth while he was growing up and his role in removing the excommunication of a bishop who is well known for denying the Holocaust. He should be clear about his condemnation of the Holocaust, but I can't imagine the Pope being expected to express the same kind of clarity regarding the crimes that Israel is currently committing against the Palestinians as he's expected to express regarding the Holocaust. It's not necessary to compare one to the other or to hold them both in opposition, just try to look at the facts here.
There was no talk coming from the Pope regarding the Palestinians murdered in Gaza just a few short months ago. While the Pope is making his rounds here, the Catholics in Gaza are locked in their open-air prison and apparently it was too political or too offensive to Israelis for the Pope to visit Gaza, even though he's probably one of the hand full of people that could actually get in there right now.
During his visit to the presidential residence in Jerusalem, the pope met the parents of Israeli soldier Gilad Schalit, who was captured by Hamas 3 years ago and is still being held in Gaza. This is a sound political move if you're trying to appeal to the average Israeli, but then you upset the families of the 11,000 Palestinians that are detained in Israeli prisons, many without charge or trial.
On Wednesday, Pope Benedict is scheduled to visit Bethlehem, the birthplace of Jesus and now a West Bank city under occupation and surrounded by a 25 foot wall that Israel has built. He will visit the Aida Refugee Camp, but Israel kindly refused to allow the platform that the Pope will speak from to be built near the separation wall, although it surrounds the refugee camp.
Much like he should have been more specific about the travesties committed against the Jews in the Holocaust, he should be more critical of the situation here in Palestine. I guess the Pope can't please everyone...or anyone on this trip.